Sarah Mae Tinnell, 39, formerly of Indianapolis, Indiana, passed away peacefully on January 5, 2026, in Lutz, Florida.

Sarah was born on June 13, 1986, in Hendricks County, Indiana, to Paul Tinnell and Cynthia Morgan. She was raised in Hazelwood, Indiana.

Sarah graduated from Cascade High School and later pursued higher education, earning her Master's Degree in Business from IUPUI in 2023. She was dedicated, hardworking, and proud of her academic accomplishments.

Above all, Sarah was a loving and devoted mother to her twin sons, Colton and Ethan Shumaker. She was their biggest supporter and could often be found cheering them on at baseball games. Sarah poured much of her energy and love into her children, friends, and family.

Sarah had a passion for travel, with St. Petersburg, Florida holding a special place in her heart.

Sarah is survived by her beloved sons, Ethan and Colton Shumaker; her significant other, Ryan Davidson; her siblings, Mea (Steve) Brown, Samantha (Ethan) Andrews, Amber (Chad) Hoffman, Mandy Mitchell, and David Mitchell; several nieces and nephews; and an enormous amount of friends whose lives she touched deeply.

Sarah was preceded in death by her parents, Paul Tinnell and Cynthia Morgan.